AI and Legal Fees: Four Hours That Change the Answer By Billy Dentino, retired attorney and founder of Talden Inc. Synthetic narration with prepared fictional exhibits; not Billy’s recorded voice or a Talden product run. [00:00:00] Would you cut the fee? Would you cut a fifty-thousand-dollar legal fee to forty thousand? In this fictional practice, the firm can charge less and improve its modeled contribution. Then four extra partner hours nearly erase the gain. Before we price the faster draft, let’s find out what it takes to finish the work. [00:00:20] Twenty completed projects. Here is the original practice: twenty comparable projects a year, every fifty-thousand-dollar fee collected. Revenue is one million dollars. Each completed project consumes thirty-five thousand dollars of assigned staff resources. That leaves three hundred thousand dollars of contribution. [00:00:43] Price the complete workflow. Now suppose a tested AI workflow can complete the same defined service, at the same acceptable quality, for twenty thousand dollars per project. That includes three hundred and seventy-five dollars of technology usage. Allow another fifty thousand a year for implementation, training, security work, and maintenance not already counted. [00:01:10] The apparently generous bargain. Charge forty thousand. Eight hundred thousand comes in. Four hundred thousand goes against project resources and usage; fifty thousand against the program. Contribution is three hundred and fifty thousand. Clients receive a twenty percent fee cut. The firm’s contribution improves by about seventeen percent. Contribution here deducts the specified resource values and program allowance, before common overhead, financing, taxes, and other excluded costs. It does not establish net profit or distributable cash. [00:01:52] What counts as finished? And “completed project” is doing work in that sentence. Our service includes the agreed commercial agreements and schedules, business-brief review, included specialist input, ordinary questions, revisions, and advice through a defined completion point. Count the checking and correction. Count the difficult exception. If the client now spends three days reconstructing the analysis, the work has found a new desk. [00:02:23] Measure the work through completion. The hours and internal costing values are on screen. They are assumptions, separate from billing rates and salaries. Before offering a real price, test comparable completed work against the same brief. Count missed material issues and client rework. Keep the difficult cases in the evidence. An issue nobody discovered is not an efficiency. [00:02:51] Now open the bank account. Now open the bank account. We saved thirty associate hours per project. Did the associate’s salary fall? In this cash version, salaries and all other existing cash spending stay unchanged. The available hours produce no extra collections. And the full fifty-thousand-dollar program allowance, plus usage, becomes new cash spending. [00:03:18] A different cash answer. The discount costs two hundred thousand in collections. Usage adds seven thousand five hundred in payments. The program adds fifty thousand. Cash is two hundred and fifty-seven thousand five hundred dollars worse, before financing or tax effects. [00:03:39] Time value is not a payroll payment. The bridge between that result and our improved contribution is three hundred and seven thousand five hundred dollars of assigned value for released staff time. In this version, none becomes a lower compensation payment. [00:03:56] Choose where the hour goes. Those hours may still be valuable. Use them for additional paid work, an avoided hire or external expense, better service, training, or a more sustainable working life. Name the benefit you intend. Count it once. One hour cannot be sold, removed from payroll, and given back to the lawyer simultaneously. [00:04:22] Follow the senior constraint. Let’s try selling more work. Across twenty projects, total time falls from one thousand nine hundred hours to nine hundred. But partner time falls only from five hundred to four hundred. [00:04:38] Capacity has an owner. Assume qualified partner attention is the constraint. We have five hundred partner hours available after all other demands, and enough associate and support capacity. At twenty partner hours per project, we can complete twenty-five projects. [00:04:59] Capacity still needs clients. Win, finish, and collect all twenty-five at forty thousand, and revenue returns to a million. Modeled contribution becomes four hundred and fifty thousand. A twenty percent price cut required twenty-five percent more volume. The spreadsheet has supplied capacity; it has not supplied clients. [00:05:22] Restored revenue leaves another question. Keep the earlier cash assumptions, with no added staffing expense, and cash is still fifty-nine thousand three hundred and seventy-five dollars below the old practice because of the new program and usage payments. Restoring revenue leaves another question to answer. [00:05:42] Change one input. Now change one input. Partner review takes twenty-four hours per project instead of twenty. [00:05:51] Four hours consume the cushion. Four extra hours, at our six-hundred-dollar resource value, cost twenty-four hundred dollars per project. Across the original twenty projects, that is forty-eight thousand. Our fifty-thousand-dollar contribution improvement becomes two thousand. [00:06:11] The five extra projects disappear. And five hundred partner hours now support only twenty whole projects. The five extra projects disappear too. Four hours have changed both the price cushion and the growth plan. Several deadlines in the same week could tighten the constraint further. [00:06:32] A price chooses how to share value. What, then, is the right price? Return to the original revised-workflow assumption: twenty partner hours per project. Keeping the old fifty-thousand-dollar fee produces five hundred and fifty thousand of contribution, a gain of two hundred and fifty thousand. At forty thousand, clients receive two hundred thousand of that gain and the firm retains fifty thousand. That eighty-twenty division follows from our selected price. It is no universal rule for sharing AI savings. [00:07:09] A reference point, not a market price. A thirty-seven-thousand-five-hundred-dollar fee preserves the original contribution at twenty projects. That is a model reference point, not a market price or assurance that overhead is covered. The client does not owe us our old contribution. [00:07:28] The competing offer. Suppose a competitor quotes thirty-five thousand. Compare the completed service, including specialist work, timing, revisions, and the client’s own burden. If it is equivalent, our spreadsheet cannot make forty thousand attractive by itself. Consider better delivery, different contribution, other work, or declining the assignment. [00:07:52] What can actually be staffed and collected? Predictable committed volume, organized inputs, or a defined assessment before fixed pricing may improve the bargain. A hoped-for pipeline deserves different treatment from work you can actually staff and collect. [00:08:08] Match the agreement to the work. Our example assumes a prospectively agreed fixed fee. For hourly work, ABA guidance permits billing actual time spent, including appropriate AI use and review, without adding back hours saved. Its advisory view also recognizes that efficiency can affect flat-fee reasonableness. [00:08:31] Local rules matter. Local rules matter. The ABA model prohibits unreasonable fees; California prohibits unconscionable or illegal fees and expressly recognizes flat fees for described services regardless of the eventual work. California generally looks to the circumstances when the agreement was made, except when the parties contemplate later events affecting the fee. Neither approach reduces the decision to a stopwatch. [00:09:03] Define what is included and earned. Define what the fee includes and when it is earned. California’s flat-fee advisory addresses refunds of unearned advances when work ends incomplete, and Rule one point eight point one safeguards for increasing the fee during the representation. Extra effort on included work does not automatically justify another charge. Nor does a technology cost in this model authorize an invoice surcharge. Florida’s advisory cautions against separately billing costs already included in overhead, or duplicating charges. The article contains the authorities and distinctions. [00:09:44] Before the next pricing conversation. Before your next pricing conversation, choose one recurring service. Measure it through completion. Reconcile the model to actual payments and collections. Put the work on the senior reviewer’s calendar. Then add four hours and see what survives. [00:10:04] Saved time needs somewhere to go. This film is by Billy Dentino, a retired attorney and the founder of Talden. At Talden A I dot com slash demo, you can examine fictional vendor-review inputs and a client brief. Use them to think through what a complete assignment requires before estimating its economics. The time you have saved still needs somewhere to go. A good offer gives both the client and the firm an honest answer about where.