AI Contract Review: Same Words, Different Deal By Billy Dentino, retired attorney and founder of Talden Inc. Synthetic narration with prepared fictional exhibits; not Billy’s recorded voice or a Talden product run. [00:00:00] What does consent control now? Would you approve this shorter contract clause? Here is the original: “Supplier may propose a price adjustment after the first contract year. No adjustment takes effect without Buyer’s prior written consent.” Here is the proposed rewrite: “With Buyer’s prior written consent, Supplier may propose a price adjustment after the first contract year.” Same parties. Same price adjustment. The familiar phrases are still there. What does consent control now? [00:00:30] The condition has moved. Try this: it is month eighteen. Buyer has given no consent. Supplier sends a request for a higher price, without implementing it. The original permits the request. The rewrite makes even that permission conditional on prior consent. The condition has moved from the adjustment taking effect to Supplier proposing it. [00:00:55] Difference is enough to reject equivalence. That does not automatically make an unapproved request a damages claim. And deleting the effectiveness condition does not, by itself, establish a unilateral right to raise prices. We have enough to reject the claim that the rewrite preserves the same mechanism. These are prepared fictional exercises. We will work through three kinds of change, then leave you with a review test for your next assignment. [00:01:23] Specify what must survive. First, make the editing instruction precise: “Preserve Supplier’s ability to propose an adjustment after year one. Preserve Buyer’s prior written consent as a condition to the adjustment taking effect. Do not make consent a condition to submitting the proposal.” Ask for supported differences before a clean draft. [00:01:48] Choose the legal function. If none is found, ask what was compared and what remains unresolved. Requiring the assistant to find a flaw invites it to invent one. Choose the legal function before polishing the verb. Is this discretion, an obligation, or a condition? Kenneth Adams’s drafting framework makes that a useful starting point, without pretending that every court treats verbs as a universal code. [00:02:14] Words that approved too much. Now change the document’s status. It is still under negotiation. Buyer has not approved signing. The assistant writes: “The contract allows price increases after year one. We can proceed to signing.” A proposed term has become a current right. An adjustment has become an increase. And somebody has apparently approved the entire deal. [00:02:40] Buyer has not approved signing. A useful update says: “Under the proposed agreement, Supplier could propose a price adjustment after the first contract year, but no adjustment would take effect without Buyer’s prior written consent. Buyer has not approved signing.” It is longer. The word count has no vote on whether the buyer approved the deal. [00:03:00] Establish the assignment’s authority. Editing to preserve a bargain, negotiating a different bargain, and explaining a signed agreement are different assignments. A consent standard, notice period, or pricing formula may deserve negotiation. Do not quietly add one. And if signed language has competing reasonable interpretations, preserve that uncertainty until there is a basis to resolve it. [00:03:25] One report. Two legal functions. Second exercise. Two provisions concern a single security report. “Vendor shall deliver the security test report to Customer by five p.m. Friday.” “Customer’s obligation to pay the deployment fee is subject to Customer’s receipt of the security test report by five p.m. Friday.” Can one replace the other? [00:03:51] Friday passes. No report. The first expresses a delivery duty. The second expressly conditions payment on a specified receipt event. A contract may need both. Friday passes. No report. Separate the questions: is payment due, and has Vendor broken a promise for which a remedy may be available? The agreement and applicable law affect those answers, including possible excuse. [00:04:19] Condition and promise are different. New York’s Merritt Hill Vineyards decision illustrates the distinction. Unmet conditions excused the buyer’s performance and entitled it to its deposit, but did not support consequential damages without an independent promise to fulfill them. A provision can perform both functions. [00:04:41] Receipt occurred. Timely receipt did not. Now the report arrives Monday. Receipt has occurred. Receipt by Friday has not. Does the bargain postpone payment until delivery, or attach another consequence to missing Friday? Establish the intended result; the isolated sentence does not settle every consequence. [00:05:04] Paying is not every waiver. Suppose Customer chooses to pay anyway. An email saying “We accept Vendor’s performance in full” might waive more than intended. Identify the payment condition being waived and the position, if any, being preserved on delivery and claims. [00:05:23] Watch the event change. One smaller edit makes the timing issue visible. The instruction says: “Vendor must deliver the report so that Customer receives it by five p.m. Pacific Time on October thirtieth.” The rewrite says: “Vendor must send the report by October thirtieth.” Receipt became dispatch. The hour and time zone disappeared. [00:05:49] Which delivery event counts? Ask which delivery rules apply to this report, including deemed receipt. The general notice clause may not govern it. An email, a portal upload, and a message that a report is ready are not automatically the same event. [00:06:06] A deadline alone is not the condition. In Oppenheimer, New York’s highest court enforced an express condition to a proposed sublease’s formation: timely delivery of the landlord’s written consent to the tenant’s work. Oral notice did not satisfy it. The court distinguished doubtful language and recognized possible excuse, finding none on that record. A deadline alone does not establish an express condition. [00:06:34] The quote can be right. The memo wrong. Third exercise. The contract is accurately quoted. The board memo is still misleading. “The indemnity fully protects Buyer against the identified exposure.” The agreement covers that category of loss, subject to a two-million-dollar aggregate cap. [00:06:53] Read the assumptions before the answer. Assume five million dollars of covered loss, an enforceable claim, every recovery condition satisfied, full collectibility, no cap exception, no deductible, no prior use of the cap, and no other recovery. Ignore recovery costs and the time value of money. [00:07:19] “Fully” has done $3 million of work. Buyer recovers two million and retains three million. The word “fully” has done three million dollars of work without asking permission. [00:07:31] Copied cap ≠ available recovery. Now earlier claims have consumed five hundred thousand of that same cap. Keep everything else unchanged. Available recovery is one and a half million. Buyer retains three and a half million on this loss. The two-million-dollar cap was copied perfectly. It was the wrong number to treat as available recovery. [00:07:57] Missing history is not an untouched cap. The contract tells you what counts against the cap. The claim record tells you what has consumed it; an amount demanded is not automatically an amount consumed. Collection has its own evidence. Missing claim history is not evidence of an untouched cap. [00:08:16] Put the retained exposure beside the assurance. Put the retained exposure beside the assurance. Say what the indemnity covers, state its limit and conditions, and identify the exposure the board must decide whether to accept or address. A reader should not have to reconcile “fully protected” on page one with the limitation on page seven. [00:08:38] Start with the operative version. Here is the review to take away. Establish the operative versions and the assignment’s authority. Describe who may or must do what, on which trigger, with which qualifications, timing, and consequence. Check the definitions and connected provisions. [00:08:59] One real difference defeats equivalence. Ask for one fact pattern that exposes a supported difference under the same facts. Check it yourself. One real difference defeats equivalence. Matching examples, or finding no difference, do not prove equivalence. [00:09:17] Check both directions. Then check both directions. Does each important assertion have support? Has each material source restriction survived into the answer? An accurately cited indemnity paragraph can still omit an exclusive-remedy provision. [00:09:36] Dispose of the issue. Finish the review by disposing of the issue: accept the intended edit, reject the unintended change, obtain instructions, or preserve an unresolved interpretation. Use the final negotiated version; an earlier review does not automatically survive a changed cap or consent clause. [00:09:58] Review depth follows the tool and task. Review depth should fit the tool and task. ABA Opinion five twelve’s contract-summary example assumes prior accuracy testing against manually reviewed contracts. Its advisory guidance does not approve sampling for every decisive provision. For the clauses carrying these recommendations, I would examine the supporting text directly. [00:10:25] Which decision did the words just make? This film is by Billy Dentino, a retired attorney and founder of Talden. For a separate practice exercise, open the fictional vendor-review materials at Talden A I dot com slash demo. Start with the business brief and ask which relationship the drafting must preserve. A useful rewrite makes the bargain easier to see. Before approving it, make sure you can explain which decision its words just made.