WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:03.580
Would you approve this shorter contract clause? Here is the original:

2
00:00:04.420 --> 00:00:08.280
“Supplier may propose a price adjustment after the first contract year.

3
00:00:08.620 --> 00:00:13.340
No adjustment takes effect without Buyer’s prior written consent.” Here is

4
00:00:13.340 --> 00:00:18.680
the proposed rewrite: “With Buyer’s prior written consent, Supplier may propose

5
00:00:18.680 --> 00:00:22.980
a price adjustment after the first contract year.” Same parties. Same

6
00:00:22.980 --> 00:00:27.460
price adjustment. The familiar phrases are still there. What does consent

7
00:00:27.460 --> 00:00:28.180
control now?

8
00:00:30.500 --> 00:00:34.480
Try this: it is month eighteen. Buyer has given no consent.

9
00:00:34.860 --> 00:00:38.740
Supplier sends a request for a higher price, without implementing it.

10
00:00:38.980 --> 00:00:43.700
The original permits the request. The rewrite makes even that permission

11
00:00:43.700 --> 00:00:48.180
conditional on prior consent. The condition has moved from the adjustment

12
00:00:48.180 --> 00:00:50.620
taking effect to Supplier proposing it.

13
00:00:55.020 --> 00:00:59.100
That does not automatically make an unapproved request a damages claim.

14
00:00:59.240 --> 00:01:04.520
And deleting the effectiveness condition does not, by itself, establish a

15
00:01:04.520 --> 00:01:08.640
unilateral right to raise prices. We have enough to reject the

16
00:01:08.640 --> 00:01:12.940
claim that the rewrite preserves the same mechanism. These are prepared

17
00:01:12.940 --> 00:01:17.640
fictional exercises. We will work through three kinds of change, then

18
00:01:17.640 --> 00:01:20.220
leave you with a review test for your next assignment.

19
00:01:24.020 --> 00:01:29.620
First, make the editing instruction precise: “Preserve Supplier’s ability to propose

20
00:01:29.620 --> 00:01:34.460
an adjustment after year one. Preserve Buyer’s prior written consent as

21
00:01:34.460 --> 00:01:38.380
a condition to the adjustment taking effect. Do not make consent

22
00:01:38.380 --> 00:01:42.840
a condition to submitting the proposal.” Ask for supported differences before

23
00:01:42.840 --> 00:01:43.700
a clean draft.

24
00:01:48.170 --> 00:01:51.520
If none is found, ask what was compared and what remains

25
00:01:51.520 --> 00:01:55.880
unresolved. Requiring the assistant to find a flaw invites it to

26
00:01:55.880 --> 00:02:00.660
invent one. Choose the legal function before polishing the verb. Is

27
00:02:00.660 --> 00:02:05.840
this discretion, an obligation, or a condition? Kenneth Adams’s drafting framework

28
00:02:05.840 --> 00:02:09.380
makes that a useful starting point, without pretending that every court

29
00:02:09.380 --> 00:02:11.320
treats verbs as a universal code.

30
00:02:14.760 --> 00:02:20.360
Now change the document’s status. It is still under negotiation. Buyer

31
00:02:20.360 --> 00:02:25.440
has not approved signing. The assistant writes: “The contract allows price

32
00:02:25.440 --> 00:02:29.900
increases after year one. We can proceed to signing.” A proposed

33
00:02:29.900 --> 00:02:33.580
term has become a current right. An adjustment has become an

34
00:02:33.580 --> 00:02:37.320
increase. And somebody has apparently approved the entire deal.

35
00:02:40.840 --> 00:02:46.300
A useful update says: “Under the proposed agreement, Supplier could propose

36
00:02:46.300 --> 00:02:49.820
a price adjustment after the first contract year, but no adjustment

37
00:02:49.820 --> 00:02:54.020
would take effect without Buyer’s prior written consent. Buyer has not

38
00:02:54.020 --> 00:02:57.980
approved signing.” It is longer. The word count has no vote

39
00:02:57.980 --> 00:02:59.860
on whether the buyer approved the deal.

40
00:03:00.810 --> 00:03:04.960
Editing to preserve a bargain, negotiating a different bargain, and explaining

41
00:03:04.960 --> 00:03:09.800
a signed agreement are different assignments. A consent standard, notice period,

42
00:03:09.940 --> 00:03:14.680
or pricing formula may deserve negotiation. Do not quietly add one.

43
00:03:14.880 --> 00:03:20.340
And if signed language has competing reasonable interpretations, preserve that uncertainty

44
00:03:20.340 --> 00:03:22.620
until there is a basis to resolve it.

45
00:03:25.920 --> 00:03:31.600
Second exercise. Two provisions concern a single security report. “Vendor shall

46
00:03:31.600 --> 00:03:35.640
deliver the security test report to Customer by five p.m. Friday.”

47
00:03:36.580 --> 00:03:40.700
“Customer’s obligation to pay the deployment fee is subject to Customer’s

48
00:03:40.700 --> 00:03:45.040
receipt of the security test report by five p.m. Friday.” Can

49
00:03:45.040 --> 00:03:45.920
one replace the other?

50
00:03:51.400 --> 00:03:56.920
The first expresses a delivery duty. The second expressly conditions payment

51
00:03:56.920 --> 00:04:01.980
on a specified receipt event. A contract may need both. Friday

52
00:04:01.980 --> 00:04:07.940
passes. No report. Separate the questions: is payment due, and has

53
00:04:07.940 --> 00:04:10.880
Vendor broken a promise for which a remedy may be available?

54
00:04:11.220 --> 00:04:16.380
The agreement and applicable law affect those answers, including possible excuse.

55
00:04:20.040 --> 00:04:25.620
New York’s Merritt Hill Vineyards decision illustrates the distinction. Unmet conditions

56
00:04:25.620 --> 00:04:30.140
excused the buyer’s performance and entitled it to its deposit, but

57
00:04:30.140 --> 00:04:34.540
did not support consequential damages without an independent promise to fulfill

58
00:04:34.540 --> 00:04:37.760
them. A provision can perform both functions.

59
00:04:41.190 --> 00:04:46.640
Now the report arrives Monday. Receipt has occurred. Receipt by Friday

60
00:04:46.640 --> 00:04:51.620
has not. Does the bargain postpone payment until delivery, or attach

61
00:04:51.620 --> 00:04:57.040
another consequence to missing Friday? Establish the intended result; the isolated

62
00:04:57.040 --> 00:04:59.620
sentence does not settle every consequence.

63
00:05:04.200 --> 00:05:09.220
Suppose Customer chooses to pay anyway. An email saying “We accept

64
00:05:09.220 --> 00:05:13.980
Vendor’s performance in full” might waive more than intended. Identify the

65
00:05:13.980 --> 00:05:18.240
payment condition being waived and the position, if any, being preserved

66
00:05:18.240 --> 00:05:19.700
on delivery and claims.

67
00:05:23.240 --> 00:05:27.820
One smaller edit makes the timing issue visible. The instruction says:

68
00:05:28.260 --> 00:05:31.440
“Vendor must deliver the report so that Customer receives it by

69
00:05:31.440 --> 00:05:36.920
five p.m. Pacific Time on October thirtieth.” The rewrite says: “Vendor

70
00:05:36.920 --> 00:05:42.000
must send the report by October thirtieth.” Receipt became dispatch. The

71
00:05:42.000 --> 00:05:43.760
hour and time zone disappeared.

72
00:05:49.340 --> 00:05:53.820
Ask which delivery rules apply to this report, including deemed receipt.

73
00:05:54.460 --> 00:05:58.440
The general notice clause may not govern it. An email, a

74
00:05:58.440 --> 00:06:01.540
portal upload, and a message that a report is ready are

75
00:06:01.540 --> 00:06:03.460
not automatically the same event.

76
00:06:07.000 --> 00:06:11.180
In Oppenheimer, New York’s highest court enforced an express condition to

77
00:06:11.180 --> 00:06:16.400
a proposed sublease’s formation: timely delivery of the landlord’s written consent

78
00:06:16.400 --> 00:06:21.120
to the tenant’s work. Oral notice did not satisfy it. The

79
00:06:21.120 --> 00:06:26.460
court distinguished doubtful language and recognized possible excuse, finding none on

80
00:06:26.460 --> 00:06:31.060
that record. A deadline alone does not establish an express condition.

81
00:06:34.640 --> 00:06:39.540
Third exercise. The contract is accurately quoted. The board memo is

82
00:06:39.540 --> 00:06:44.500
still misleading. “The indemnity fully protects Buyer against the identified exposure.”

83
00:06:44.800 --> 00:06:49.260
The agreement covers that category of loss, subject to a two-million-dollar

84
00:06:49.260 --> 00:06:50.400
aggregate cap.

85
00:06:53.820 --> 00:06:58.820
Assume five million dollars of covered loss, an enforceable claim, every

86
00:06:58.820 --> 00:07:04.760
recovery condition satisfied, full collectibility, no cap exception, no deductible, no

87
00:07:04.760 --> 00:07:09.560
prior use of the cap, and no other recovery. Ignore recovery

88
00:07:09.560 --> 00:07:11.620
costs and the time value of money.

89
00:07:19.200 --> 00:07:23.640
Buyer recovers two million and retains three million. The word “fully”

90
00:07:23.640 --> 00:07:26.940
has done three million dollars of work without asking permission.

91
00:07:31.750 --> 00:07:35.260
Now earlier claims have consumed five hundred thousand of that same

92
00:07:35.260 --> 00:07:40.539
cap. Keep everything else unchanged. Available recovery is one and a

93
00:07:40.539 --> 00:07:45.160
half million. Buyer retains three and a half million on this

94
00:07:45.160 --> 00:07:50.360
loss. The two-million-dollar cap was copied perfectly. It was the wrong

95
00:07:50.360 --> 00:07:52.140
number to treat as available recovery.

96
00:07:57.530 --> 00:08:01.300
The contract tells you what counts against the cap. The claim

97
00:08:01.300 --> 00:08:04.760
record tells you what has consumed it; an amount demanded is

98
00:08:04.760 --> 00:08:10.300
not automatically an amount consumed. Collection has its own evidence. Missing

99
00:08:10.300 --> 00:08:13.280
claim history is not evidence of an untouched cap.

100
00:08:16.860 --> 00:08:21.280
Put the retained exposure beside the assurance. Say what the indemnity

101
00:08:21.280 --> 00:08:25.780
covers, state its limit and conditions, and identify the exposure the

102
00:08:25.780 --> 00:08:30.020
board must decide whether to accept or address. A reader should

103
00:08:30.020 --> 00:08:33.880
not have to reconcile “fully protected” on page one with the

104
00:08:33.880 --> 00:08:35.480
limitation on page seven.

105
00:08:39.080 --> 00:08:42.920
Here is the review to take away. Establish the operative versions

106
00:08:42.920 --> 00:08:47.760
and the assignment’s authority. Describe who may or must do what,

107
00:08:47.940 --> 00:08:53.780
on which trigger, with which qualifications, timing, and consequence. Check the

108
00:08:53.780 --> 00:08:55.540
definitions and connected provisions.

109
00:08:59.130 --> 00:09:03.060
Ask for one fact pattern that exposes a supported difference under

110
00:09:03.060 --> 00:09:08.480
the same facts. Check it yourself. One real difference defeats equivalence.

111
00:09:09.180 --> 00:09:13.960
Matching examples, or finding no difference, do not prove equivalence.

112
00:09:17.375 --> 00:09:23.340
Then check both directions. Does each important assertion have support? Has

113
00:09:23.340 --> 00:09:28.700
each material source restriction survived into the answer? An accurately cited

114
00:09:28.700 --> 00:09:32.580
indemnity paragraph can still omit an exclusive-remedy provision.

115
00:09:36.010 --> 00:09:39.940
Finish the review by disposing of the issue: accept the intended

116
00:09:39.940 --> 00:09:46.200
edit, reject the unintended change, obtain instructions, or preserve an unresolved

117
00:09:46.200 --> 00:09:51.700
interpretation. Use the final negotiated version; an earlier review does not

118
00:09:51.700 --> 00:09:55.100
automatically survive a changed cap or consent clause.

119
00:09:58.580 --> 00:10:05.613
Review depth should fit the tool and task. ABA Opinion five

120
00:10:05.613 --> 00:10:11.440
twelve’s contract-summary example assumes prior accuracy testing against manually reviewed

121
00:10:11.440 --> 00:10:16.480
contracts. Its advisory guidance does not approve sampling for every decisive

122
00:10:16.480 --> 00:10:21.080
provision. For the clauses carrying these recommendations, I would examine the

123
00:10:21.080 --> 00:10:22.320
supporting text directly.

124
00:10:25.685 --> 00:10:29.840
This film is by Billy Dentino, a retired attorney and founder

125
00:10:29.840 --> 00:10:34.960
of Talden. For a separate practice exercise, open the fictional vendor-review

126
00:10:34.960 --> 00:10:40.240
materials at Talden A I dot com slash demo. Start with

127
00:10:40.240 --> 00:10:43.980
the business brief and ask which relationship the drafting must preserve.

128
00:10:43.980 --> 00:10:48.960
A useful rewrite makes the bargain easier to see. Before approving

129
00:10:48.960 --> 00:10:52.380
it, make sure you can explain which decision its words just

130
00:10:52.380 --> 00:10:52.680
made.
